2014_Lorenzo Cain, Kansas City
2013_Koji Uehara, Boston
2012_Delmon Young, Detroit
2011_Nelson Cruz, Texas
2010_Josh Hamilton, Texas
2009_CC Sabathia, Nueva York (Yanquis)
2008_Matt Garza, Tampa Bay
2007_Josh Beckett, Boston
2006_Placido Polanco, Detroit
2005_Paul Konerko, Chicago (Medias Blancas)
2004_David Ortiz, Boston
2003_Mariano Rivera, Nueva York (Yanquis)
2002_Adam Kennedy, Anaheim (Angelinos)
2001_Andy Pettitte, Nueva York (Yanquis)
2000_David Justice, Nueva York (Yanquis)
1999_Orlando Hernández, Nueva York (Yanquis)
1998_David Wells, Nueva York (Yanquis)
1997_Marquis Grissom, Cleveland
1996_Bernie Williams, Nueva York (Yanquis)
1995_Orel Hershiser, Cleveland
1994_campaña cancelada por huelga
1993_Dave Stewart, Toronto
1992_Roberto Alomar, Toronto
1991_Kirby Puckett, Minnesota
1990_Dave Stewart, Oakland
1989_Rickey Henderson, Oakland
1988_Dennis Eckersley, Oakland
1987_Gary Gaetti, Minnesota
1986_Marty Barrett, Boston
1985_George Brett, Kansas City
1984_Kirk Gibson, Detroit
1983_Mike Boddicker, Baltimore
1982_Fred Lynn, California (Angelinos)
1981_Graig Nettles, Nueva York (Yanquis)
1980_Frank White, Kansas City
